Best pizza in this area! Wait staff is always great. Excellent food, service & reasonable prices make it a great place to visit! Def recommend if you're in the area, looking for good pizza...they have a wide variety of Italian food on their menu, which I haven't tried but I'm sure is great also because their pizza is so good! It will become your new favorite pizza place!

Kendra O.

Nice small place to go-to hang out, have a few drinks & wings, especially on Tuesday wing night, love when Tuesday comes around, nice cheap wings. All and all this place is great to hang out with friends or co-workers & just relax 5/5

Mikey M.

Friendly place and service was very good. The food and drinks were great!!! Prices are reasonable also!

Rose N.

I have come here for over 20 years..... and I can't imagine not having Alfredo's as an option while in the New Milford area. The food has remained stellar.... best eggplant Parmesan in the universe - hands down. And hopefully you're lucky to come on a cream puff night...

Ben S.

Best Italian food in Connecticut!! Went back after 20 years away and the food was a great as I remembered!!

Heather C.

Always great food and good size portions prices are good. Great service

Robert S

Great food, great service. I love so many of their menu items! Always have great specials, too. One of my favorites is the Broccoli Rabe w/ Sausage over Cavatelli. Yum! The burgers are huge and the meat is so fresh! The pizza is delicious. Salads are fresh and crispy. The prices are very, very reasonable. The atmosphere is very casual and the owners and staff are super friendly, accommodating and fun. It's a "Cheers" kind of place

Kim S.

Great place for any food. Great hospitality

Ralph L.

I really like the food and the waitress was very friendly and helpful

Debra G.

Had a takeout pizza one night and ate in another night - food was pretty good and was good value. Great atmosphere and friendly locals!


I love the pizza at Alfredo's!!! Their happy hour is terrific and you will always have a wonderful time here, especially when meeting friends!!


Alfredo's Restaurant & Pizza has remained a great dinning spot for 30 years under the same ownership. Worth the trip to the village of Gaylordsville to taste the fine Italian foods from pasta dishes, tortellini, daily specials and of course Pizza. Great owners and staff and a nice little side bar. Worth the trip, enjoy. Pete & Toni PS Great takeout


We eat here most Wednesday's as our favorite bartender is on duty. The food is good and reasonable. The building is a little older, but the dining room is cute as bottles hang from the ceiling marking special occasions.


Good food and great service. Will cook to your preference. Lunch specials are priced accordingly and generous portions. Dinners are larger portions and of course the pizza is great.


We had a lovely family evening at Alfredo's! It's a cute place with a nice decor and very family oriented. We enjoyed our food and wine and the whole atmosphere. We'd definitely recommend it for a night out!

Joyce S